The ULTIMATE Leader Board

This is the ULTIMATE mince pie leader board as rated by 
The Mince Pie Administration 



Here you will find the greatest mince pies the Mince Pie Administration has tasted over the years.

Each pie is marked out of 100 points. The closer to the haloed 100 it gets the closer you are to heaven when eating one (well, I am at least!).

Points are given in various areas.
  • 10 points - Presentation
  • 10 points - Nutritional content & Price
  • 35 points - Pastry
  • 35 points - Mincemeat
  • 10 points - Satisfaction level 
So, lets see where everyone have been rated.
(Click on each entry to take you to the review) 

1.   Harrods Alcohol-Free Cranberry Mince Pies (90.7 in 2013)
2.   Heston Blumenthal 6 Spiced Shortcrust Mince Pies (86.7 in 2013)
3.   Greggs 6 Sweet Mince Pies (85.5 in 2013)
4.   Costa - Mince Tart (85.3 in 2013)
5.   Costco - Kirkland Signature - Mince Pies (81 in 2013)
6.   Lidl - Snowy Lodge - 6 Luxury Mince Pies (76.9 in 2013)
7.   Marks & Spencer - 6 All Butter Mince Pies (75.75 in 2013)
8.   Aldi - Specially Selected - 6 Mince Pies (75 in 2014)
9.   Waitrose Christmas - 6 Shortcrust Mince Pies (73.7 in 2013)
10.  Riverford Farm Shop - Organic Mince Pies (72.7 in 2013)
11.  Selfridges & Co - 6 Nut Topped Mince Pies (72.5 in 2013)
12.  The Co-Operative - Loved by us - 6 Deep Filled Mince Pies (68 in 2015)
13.  Sainsbury's - Christmas by Sainsbury's 6 Deep Mince Pies (65.5 in 2013)
14.  Sainsburys - Taste the Difference - 6 All Butter Mince Pies (65.5 in 2013)
15.  Harvey Nichols - Twelve Mini Mince Pies (62.7 in 2013)
16.  Spar - 6 Mince Pies (62 in 2015)
17.  Morrisons - Signature - All Butter Deep Filled Mince Pies (62 in 2014)
18.  Duchy Originals from Waitrose - Organic Mince Pies (59.3 in 2013)
19.  Tesco Finest - All Butter Pastry - 6 Deed Filled Mince Pies (57 in 2015)
20.  Fortnum & Mason Six Traditional Christmas Mince Pies (56.6 in 2013
21.  Morrisons Christmas 9 Mini Mince Pies (55.9 in 2013)
22.  Tesco Christmas Mince Pies (55.63 in 2013)
23.  Udi's Gluten Free - Mince Pies (55.5 in 2013)
24.  Mr Kipling -Exceedingly Merry - 6 Mince Pies (55 in 2014)
25.  BHS Deep Filled Mince Pie (54.3 in 2013)
26.  Morrisons Festive Mince Pies (54 in 2014)
27.  Walkers - Glenfiddich - 8 Luxury Mincemeat Tarts (52.3 in 2013)
28.  Harrods - Walnut & Honey Mince Pies (51 in 2014)
29.  Iceland 6 Deep Fill Mince Pies (51 in 2013)
30.  Morrisons Christmas Deep Filled Mince Pies (50.3 in 2013)
31.  Asda - Extra Special - 6 Luxury Mince Pies (49 in 2015)
32.  Tesco Finest* 12 Mini Mince Pies (42.5 in 2013)
33.  Pret A Manger - Mince Pie (42.3 in 2013)
34.  Poundland - Hoppers Farmhouse Bakeries - 9 Mince Pies (34.9 in 2013)
35Asda - Have a Classic Christmas - 6 Mince Pies (32 in 2015)